Feedback

This is where you can post about your trading experiences in the Gnoblar Market, helping highlight good or bad traders for the benefit of other Stronghold members.

For example:

Bob the Ogre is a great trader, everything went smoothly and the items arrived quickly. Thanks!

Feel free to give your trading buddy a Pet Gnoblar as thanks for a positive trading experience!

Brutus the Blue delivered my model very quickly, despite it being Christmas and despite living many miles away.

Krud sent me a huge Beastmen lot in trade for my Skaven lot. He shipped first as he had lower trade ratings on the Net, but was EXTREMELY efficient, with good communication, fast shipping and overall a GREAT experience!

Trade with confidence!

BlughTheIronMaw was very easy to deal with, honest, and shipped very quickly upon getting the beastmen I sent him. I would definitely trade with him in the future! 

kingcatto was a great buyer, easy to deal with, quick payment and no hassle

Khorgoth Corpseheart was very pleasant to deal with. We traded some stuff and everything got here in great condition very quickly. Great levels of communication too, I'd reccommend dealing with him to anyone

Thanks
Corai

I received my first trade from Corai yesterday. He is an excellent trade partner with good communication throughout and I would recommend him to all.

Likewise Tim C was great to deal with. We did a straight sale and he paid immediatley with no problems. Certianly recommended

thanks
Corai

Traded with Krud again, again perfect service all around!

Will always trade with him!

Done adeal with Sycorax, great communication and fast payment would deal with again.

Traded with BlughtheIronmaw again; everything went off without a hitch! Great trader! 

completed a transaction with Spawnchomper, delivered well packaged and quickly. would deal again. good trade

syc.

I too just completed a deal with Spawnchomper, excellent trader! Would definitely deal with again!

completed a trade with Blugh the Ironmaw, great communication through out, item posted quickly. Very happy with trade. Would deal with again.

jamisarrius hasn't been online for the past month, so I don't know if he got the package or not, but he is a great person to do business with; totally reccomended.

and i just remembered I never gave feedback to Wildcard, for the Rhinox rider I sent him almost a year ago... great buyer and great person (but we all knew that).

cheers

Once again did a great deal with Corai thanks for the trade again mate and once again I VERY HIGHLY RECOMMEND him to all. Top bloke.

again, TimC was a pleasure to deal with. Highly rated all round.

I also just completed a trade wiht Stonedog who had fantastic comms and also comes highly recommended!

Thanks
Corai

Just completed a trade with Corai... Highly recommended, well packaged and on time

Cheers

khorgoth_corpseheart = excellent trader!

I traded him a sizeable amount of orcs (an army box + 2 sets of BFSP night goblins and some other odds and ends). In return he was sending me a comparable sized chaos lot. From the start, I agreed to ship to him first, and after a small post office address screw up everything arrived to him on.

After that he mailed the chaos lot off. After two months, I had not received anything from the post office, and it looked like nothing was coming. Throughout this time, khorgoth and i communicated, and he said he would take the issue up with the post office if nothing showed up. He had insured the shipment just in case any issues arose. Sure enough, the chaos lot never arrived.

Within a day of asking khorgoth if we could get the claim process rolling, he told me he had started it with the post office. Within a week, it was resolved and the money was in my paypal account.

Although I never ended up getting my models (through no fault of his) I would absolutely recommend him as a trader on these boards, or anywhere else. He was honest, up front, and when an issue came up, he was very quick to resolve. All around communication was excellent, and he was very friendly. Thanks for the great service. Trade on!

Krud thankyou for the feedback im really annoyed the trade didnt go ahead as planned but i am glad you were happy with the outcome.Im glad we communicated and were able to get this resolved as soon as possible.It has been a pleasure dealing with you and i hope to trade again sometime (and this time ill use a different post service ) I recommend krud to anyone hes been an amazing seller and even when problems arose he was mature about it and helped to speed up resolving the problem.All round a great guy really! I really thankyou krud and i  really appreciate the good feedback,this was my first trade to go wrong so i was  about it but thankyou for being a great guy about it.

just completed a transaction with corai, highly reccommended

very well packaged and very quick transaction

I just got through buying from Krud, he was a great seller!  Highly recommended!

Thanks again for the purchase korgoth! I would recommend him to anyone-- very clear communication and prompt payment. Trade with confidence!

just finished a good trade with Stonedog . .

Excellent trader ,to his word and posted on time !! Nice one matey thanks !!

Traded with LotrCrown, excellent and highly recommended, posted on time and nice to deal with

Cheers

and just finished a good trade with BLACKMAW . . .

same has to be said for him that i said about Stonedog !! brilliant trader and to his word !!

Thanks for the trade buddy and a MERRY CHRISTMAS to you !!

I did a good trade with Jonsolo,  even though it was a transatlantic swap it all smoothly with no problems.

Reccomended.

Great Trade and Great Communication from Fantasy Freak.  Highly recommended!

I shipped the Ogre Hunter model to jason henrichs (don't remember his stronghold nick name), who lives in the US, January 7th 2008.
After 20 days the model hasn't arrived yet, and he opened a controversy within paypal.
I, for good realtionship, gave him the money back, 'cause I don't have a tracking number,  but, this post is just to say that it takes quite a lot of time for something to arrive in the US, when shipped from Italy.
MSherman, Wildcard and Corai (to name a few members who I shipped to) can confirm this.

So, to conclude this, let me say that the transaction with Jason Henrichs was not a pleasent one, so, beware people... be aware.

thanx


cheers

I've just sold some stuff to Roon3y - a very pleasant fellow who's payment was swift and his messages cordial.

ironguts are on their way!

I've just sold some stuff to Roon3y - a very pleasant fellow who's payment was swift and his messages cordial.

ironguts are on their way!

Guts received - well packaged - everything there - im very pleased :0)

Many thanks to Wildcard - trusted seller and very nice fellow to boot :0))

Roon3y

Just completed a(nother!) Trade with Stonedog. If you have to hear my praise for this chap then you've not read a lot of the other entries in the feedback thread so far

Thouroughly recommended

Thanks
Corai

Recieved my model from LotrCrown today. It arrived perfectly packed, and it was in perfect condition Would recommend to anyone. He is polite, helpful, maintains constant contact, and an overall great trader

Thanks,

Josh

and . . . . . . i have to say the same about josh !! very nice to deal with and payed very fast !!

recomended to everyone !!

As Corai said, another trade completed and as good as ever.. as always, recommended

BlughTheIronMaw - a man of his word, excellent to trade with.

StoneDog - chalk up another flawless transaction, a total pleasure to trade with

And indeed a pleasure to trade with yourself WC

*edit* Just completed a trade with Methusula... everything came through fine & well packaged, another good trade

Completed trade with StoneDog, no complaints at all - communicated well, I'd trade again. Cheers!

Received itmes from StoneDog, and they were in great condition!!! Great guy to trade with Would recommend to all

JJ

Traded with Just-Josh... great guy to trade with, minor delay but kept in communication and everything arrived well packed... happily trade again

Just completed a trade with Roon3y, a great guy to deal with and totally relaible - happily recommended.

Traded some Dwarves with Wildcard - paid immediately - great comms and a friendly guy.

Many thanks - highly recommend.

Pete   

Completed a trade with Auca, another good trade and highly recommended

completed a trade with Corai - totally relaible, punctual and friendly.  All the usual you've come to expect.

many thanks (and I'll take good care of them),

Wildcard.

I was going to leave some glowing feedback for Wildcard but anyone who needs me to tell tem what a great guy he is clearly hasn't been paying much attention

Needless to say, friendly, reliable and great to deal with

Thanks
Corai

just did a deal with stonedog, absolute brilliant. a pleasure to do buissness with.

hope to deal with him in the future   

Dealt with mikemyers, very quick to send and very well packaged... nice doing business and well recommended

Just completed a sale with Ikim (me selling, he buying). The whole thig went off without a hitch. A Great guy, good comms maintained throughout.

Thanks
Corai

Completed another trade, this time with FantasyFreak and again completed without a hitch

Just thought i'd also put a general piece of feedback down that is i've traded quite alot through here now and so far haven't encountered a single hitch that hasn't been sorted quickly with the person i was trading with... overall the amount of consideration and courtesy i've found trading on here is astounding... keep it up everyone

Just done a nice trade with StoneDog.

Nicely packaged, no problems at all, good guy.

I would just like to make a small announcement If anyone is looking for commission sculpting services, I would sincerely like to suggest one of our fellow members here at the Stronghold I recently employed BlughTheIronMaw for a commission sculpt of the new DoC character, Ku'gath Plaguefather, and he has done an incredible job He has maintained constant contact, with regular updates, both descriptive, and photographical His price is really competitive, and the quality of his work rivals a lot of GW's own sculpts He is well worth consulting on your next sculpting project!

JJ

Also, I have just completed a trade with BigD Great communication, brilliant price, stuff arrived super quick

JJ

Just completed a trade with Jacoo - great guy... friendly communication ... would deal with again.

Pete 

I had a deal with just-josh. He's friendly in communications and quick to pay for the models!

BigD

just completed a trade with khorgoth corpseheart nice and easy willingly trade with again

Alas, i have been quite lax in updating the Feedback Thread... Not that i've had any trouble but the people ought to have the recognition for being good to trade with

Aaron, Sycorax, Korgoth Corpseheart (minor delays but great communication so no problems), Corai and Just-Josh

I apologise if i've missed anyone... really need to remember to do this straight after each trade

Thanks again to Stonedog for another awesome trade Great communication, and the items were incredible again

Great to put a name to the face finally

JJ

completed a trade with corai great coms and great to deal with (good to off met you at gd)
anton

Also, completed a trade with Corai Well, techincally two, and they were more sales, than trades Nonetheless, an awesome trader

JJ

Great thanks to StoneDog for helping me out with Slayer Doomseeker models! Hope we can do more trades in the future!

Another multiple thanks thread time my own fault for not thinking enough to do this at the time

So another set of great trades and no problems with:
Randroid
Zabo
Corai
... and apologies if i've missed someone on that list

had a trade with stonedog with a minor delay on my part but everything went ok

stonedog is amazing yet another trade has gone excellent with him! got more on the way aswell

Do not trade with Mr.Stabby, we did a trade, it's been 2 months and I havn't gotten my stuff in return, I am veeerrrryyyy angry ( I had to delete my swear word that was here before ) he stole my 3000 magic cards! 

Zabo, as angry as you are (understandably, although I don't know the full story...) please don't swear

JJ

Zabo, as angry as you are (understandably, although I don't know the full story...) please don't swear

JJ

Oh, sorry I didn't realise I had that there.

umm from intrest i have to ask:

what does ogre stronghold do when someone gets scammed in the gnoblar market?

trading rules are clear:

In order to trade Games Workshop items fairly, please note the following rules:

1. Trades must not be false, inaccurate or misleading.  Hobby related trades only please.

2. Do not infringe any third party's copyright, patent, trade mark, trade secret or other proprietary rights or rights of publicity or privacy

3. Fraudulent traders or traders involved in the sale of counterfeit or stolen items will be banned on the spot.

4. Do not be in breach of any applicable laws or regulations (including, but not limited to, laws governing export control, consumer protection, unfair competition, anti-discrimination, false advertising).

5. You agree to indemnify and hold the website and its owner harmless from any claim or demand, including but not limited to reasonable legal fees, made by any third party due to or arising out of your breach of this User Agreement (including the documents incorporated by reference), or your violation of any law or the rights of a third party.

6. This agreement shall be governed by and construed in accordance with UK law and subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of the UK courts.

7. By agreeing to this document, you stipulate that you cannot hold the owner, website or anyone connected to it to any legal claims under any manner or circumstance, regardless of your own circumstances.

8. You agree that this service is provided free to those who use it. You are responsible for tax and any other costs arising.


Please take care when trading folks.
If you're buying something from an unfamiliar member, it is recommended that you ask for photo evidence of the minis first.
If you're selling some of your own minis, always ask for payment first.

We can "moderate" a little in this area, but really trading is the responsibility of the two trading parties.

Fortunatly, with a friendly and familiar little community we have here, its not often a problem and most issues are not "scamming" rather than misunderstandings.

ookay.. thanks for the input!

trading rules are clear:

In order to trade Games Workshop items fairly, please note the following rules:

1. Trades must not be false, inaccurate or misleading.  Hobby related trades only please.

2. Do not infringe any third party's copyright, patent, trade mark, trade secret or other proprietary rights or rights of publicity or privacy

3. Fraudulent traders or traders involved in the sale of counterfeit or stolen items will be banned on the spot.

4. Do not be in breach of any applicable laws or regulations (including, but not limited to, laws governing export control, consumer protection, unfair competition, anti-discrimination, false advertising).

5. You agree to indemnify and hold the website and its owner harmless from any claim or demand, including but not limited to reasonable legal fees, made by any third party due to or arising out of your breach of this User Agreement (including the documents incorporated by reference), or your violation of any law or the rights of a third party.

6. This agreement shall be governed by and construed in accordance with UK law and subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of the UK courts.

7. By agreeing to this document, you stipulate that you cannot hold the owner, website or anyone connected to it to any legal claims under any manner or circumstance, regardless of your own circumstances.

8. You agree that this service is provided free to those who use it. You are responsible for tax and any other costs arising.


Please take care when trading folks.
If you're buying something from an unfamiliar member, it is recommended that you ask for photo evidence of the minis first.
If you're selling some of your own minis, always ask for payment first.

We can "moderate" a little in this area, but really trading is the responsibility of the two trading parties.

Fortunatly, with a friendly and familiar little community we have here, its not often a problem and most issues are not "scamming" rather than misunderstandings.

It might be a missunderstanding, I hope it is ( RELLY WANT THOSE DWARFS! ), however no matter how many times I try to PM him he never responds, remember when I had to make an entire thread just to get him to respond........ once, still havn't gotten them and I am tired of waiting.

Minor update time again:
Trades with Warboss "korgoth" Bogoff & CaptainChaos88, both great traders... again, apologies to CC88 for the minor delay

Ok Zabo, nice try.

Here's what's really going on.

He tried to send mt 120 dollars worth of magic cards from recent sets. What I got was about 60 bucks worth of crap rares and old commons and other junk. As an act of good faith, I have sent him the cards BACK as well as the dwarfs, for nothing in return.

Zabo has not tried to contact me in a month do discuss what we should do. I was the last one to make contact, and was waiting for a reply to see if that was good for him, and he has not. So I decided to go ahead and send it today since he won't respond.

Don't try and smear me Zabo, when it was you who made this trade go afoul with false advertising. You'll be getting FREE dwarves and your cards back soon, and I'll send you the tracking number ASAP. Don't try to smear my name again.

Ok Zabo, nice try.

Here's what's really going on.

He tried to send mt 120 dollars worth of magic cards from recent sets. What I got was about 60 bucks worth of crap rares and old commons and other junk. As an act of good faith, I have sent him the cards BACK as well as the dwarfs, for nothing in return.

Zabo has not tried to contact me in a month do discuss what we should do. I was the last one to make contact, and was waiting for a reply to see if that was good for him, and he has not. So I decided to go ahead and send it today since he won't respond.

Don't try and smear me Zabo, when it was you who made this trade go afoul with false advertising. You'll be getting FREE dwarves and your cards back soon, and I'll send you the tracking number ASAP. Don't try to smear my name again.

dude whenever I send you a message with the words figures, cards, dwarfs, or magic, you never respond I HAVE sent you messages, you just never reply. Also I sent you what you wanted, 3000 magic cards and 145 rares, with a few hundred extras from my friends, THATS what I sent. I am just angry because you said you sent the items about, 4 times, you never have, how can I trust that you sent them now? I can only get you to talk when I go into public.

A good 2000+ of those cards were from either shards, shadowmoor, or eventide. BRAND SPANKIN' NEW!

Many thanks to Craken for speedy delivery on some items all the way from Canada to the UK.
+1

Ha no worries, thanks
Question where do I find the pictures of the gnoblars (the little animated ones)?

Question where do I find the pictures of the gnoblars (the little animated ones)?

Look under the smileys when you're creating a new post, you should see a [more] link there. Click on that and a little pop-up containing all the animated Ogres, Gnoblars etc will appear.

Thanks.  Very proud of my Gnoblar I shall call him squishy

Great trade with Natalie, would happily deal with again and would recommend to all.

Excellant trade with Wildcard

Will be getting the other off you too

Natalie

Hragged was great to trade with gave even more than I asked for

Hi all, Bought some models off Zsoulless! Came very fast!! Well packed! and look better then in photos!!!

Redbull

Traded with ohGr
Patient polite and all round sterling gentleman, superfast delivery and brilliant trader,
Would recomend
TLK!

Just dealt with the above Thunder lord klement, trustworthy, courteous, great communication, grammatically sound and a black belt in packaging!

I did two separate trades with him so not sure if it's a +1 or 2, regardless 100% recommended.

Pet gnoblar for you for helping me start my own O.K army

Byron

Had trade with Byronic ^
Very kind and helpful, trustworthy with great communications. Sterling guy and would trade with again, reccomend to all!

Cheers,
TLK

Traded with Lolo The Red and Potter666
Both communicated well and were a pleasure to trade with - would reccomend both

Thanks again,
TLK

Traded with sabertux - great communication, super fast shipping. Would certainly trade with him again.

Cheers!

Great trade with Talonz, fast at sending out, no problems and great comms.

Thanks.

Great trade with Talonz, fast at sending out, no problems and great comms.

Thanks.

Likewise!

I purchased and received 2 different items from MawMuncha. He gave great communication, easy to deal business with, polite, and his packaging was spot-on sweet! The package had to go overseas and considering it was a built ironblaster and 4 leadbelchers.. not a single thing was broken, cracked or even unglued.

That's +2 and a 100% from me! Highly recommended and no worries.

 - Lord Cedric

Great trade with Prophet

Just realised the Feedback section exists....

Great trade with Hragged (once again) top drawer stuff!

Potter666 sold me some Ogre helmeted heads. Good to deal with!

Just seen Homenutt's post and wanted to recipricate-Great to deal with and a genuinely nice guy-Can't go wrong

Have a Gnoblar

Good deal with the Overtyrant himself. Fantastic!

Had an excellent purchase with Wolf Gutcracker. Great communication, Great packing! Sent much more then I expected.
Have the first gnoblar I've given out.

Great trade with Corlon - good communication, patient with my slow funds transfer, and fast shipping. Thanks!

Had a Great trade with Potter666. Great communication and quick ship. Would gladly trade with again. gnoblar gladly given.

A Gnoblar for Shawn for being a great trader and a genuine pleasure to deal with 

An Ogre amongst Thinlings and a Tyrant amongst Tyrants-Huzzah!

Traded with Unclebuck, smooth transaction no problems
TLK

Bought from GutMuscle
Would buy from him anytime, a quick efficient sale with very fast postage.

Traded with Hragged!

Got my loot all the way from the Old World with no problems.

Thanks!

Hi, just wanted to say that i've traded with Lord Cedric 3 times now, awesome guy, no problems with paying, was very happy with the items he recieved. Great person to do business with

Excellent trading experience with Thunder Lord Klement. Will very happily buy from him again.

done some commision work for Jusebert, very quick payment and an honest member

Traded my Tyrant (NIB) with Homenutt for his Firebelly (NIB).  Everything went smoothly and I would trade with him again.

did a swap with Az_barag went ok.

As above, did a trade with Jonnyandbex went really well, got my parcel 2 days after he received his, will definately do a trade again

Az

Just got my Items from frenchyakamd, excelent trader, replied to emails, was quick to send and confirm. Awesome.

Sold 12 Ogres to hmjeus.  Was an excellent buyer, paid quickly and had good communication.  I recommend trading with him in the future.

-Snark

As above, Ogres arrived really well packed and exactly as described.  Would also recommend trading with Snarkhunter in future.

did a trade with kory63 everything went fine

ive since traded again with az-barag, once again had no problems all went realy well, would reccomend tradeing with him

Traded with MikeyC, great deal: fast, good communication, and got more than I expected. Would absolutely deal with him again.

Could people Please put in the description what country they are selling from. This would greatly help as some traders are in the USA and some in other countries. As i am looking to build up my ogre army it would greatly help me to avoid making offers to people only to find out that postage can be a nightmare from overseas ( not to mention new import taxes). It would help people decide more quickly if it is a deal they want to enter into and prevent the wasting of other peoples time.

I dont want to get a negative name on the forum because i offered someone $45 for £45 worth of models without postage or visa versa (as i'm from the uk) only for it to go belly up when the mistake was realised.

Traded with Hragged and FantasyFreak both were a pleasure to deal with and transaction went smoothly,
Also dealt with ose even though he lived in Canada and me in the UK the transaction went smoothly and arrived ahead of estimated delivery time.
All three were polite and helpful and now I have a new ogre army!
TLK

+1 to Sealie

Thanks
Time of Madness

Time of Madness A+
Thanks mate.

Xanaq is a good trader, deal went through without a hitch. Recommended

Great trade with Ibisson
Cheers buddy.