The Ogre Stronghold

The first and largest home of the Ogre Kingdoms — preserved.

Filter by date range

Standalone from the search box above — this queries Pagefind directly and checks each result's date itself, since the packaged search widget can only match a single exact date, not a range.

Charging in order to not allow Charge Reaction?

original thread ↗

I'm curious about one thing that has been happening a fair bit as of lately.

An example: http://img84.imageshack.us/img84/407/chargingbutcherof0.gif [PIC]

The enemy player declares an charge against your Butcher, although it's obvious that he won't be able to reach him. It's obvious to the opponent that he will run into the units of Maneaters (charging them). Would the Maneaters be allowed to do an "Stand & Shoot" reaction although the charge was not declared against them? What about "Getting as many models into contact as possible?"

It's obvious to the enemy player that the charge will allow him to bind up two of your units. Would this be seen as an smart strategy or abuse of rules in order to get an unfair advantage?
a unit that is charged will always get a charge reaction.  In this case, the maneaters would be able to stand and shoot.

the rulebook says that if an "enemy is in the way" then a charge is declared against them and that unit gets to react as normal.

BRB p.23
x105 - keeping pace with my wins!

Ogre achievements: 65/101 latest: maneater (play in 5 different venues)

Latest Fantasy Result: ogre kingdoms vs. high elves - 1500 points - win!

8th edition: 105/25/12
New ogres: 36/6/5

I was born and bred in a briar patch!
Yeah with an in the way situation the unit declares a charge against a closer unit.  That unit flees revealing another unit.  The charging unit can declare a new charge if it chooses.  So since you have to declare a new charge you can take any reactions you want.

In that situation you could not declare a charge against the butcher because you could not complete the movement.
I'm not a Tyrant.  I'm a lone Hunter.

Quote from: Manowar on Oct 03, 2009, 04:28:17 PM
Oniguma, the only rules prosecutor in the Warhammer world.
Would this be seen as an smart strategy or abuse of rules in order to get an unfair advantage?

If it was legit (which it isn't for reasons stated in above posts), it wouldn't be a smart use of strategy, it would be someone being a dick in a game of toy soldiers :x
Quote from: Thunder lord klement on Aug 12, 2011, 04:39:47 PM
You can't be old and wise, and have youthful memory... even if you are FF 

Achievements 39/101

Latest: 9. Sigh! - lose more than 3 ogres to any one casting of a spell that involved you taking an initiative test as part of it's resolution


W/L/D : 9/10/2
Illegal charge.  Nuff said.
Continue this conversation on GitHub ↗

Opens a new GitHub Issue pre-filled with a link back here — sign in with GitHub to post. If someone already restarted this thread, please add to that issue instead of opening a second one.